Comments on: SLUMDOG POLITICS http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/ Thu, 29 Sep 2011 12:27:51 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Abhiram http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-34 Abhiram Tue, 24 Mar 2009 05:39:18 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-34 "If that’s the case then why do we have a law for child labour..in that case too parents and children are fine but it is punishable under Indian law.." I definetly feel child would have a problem If he is provided the taste of good education he will never go work.....Then child right commission should act.....Indian child right law is too complicated so I feel it is waste to comment on that.....more number of rules will result more complications... "It was not a sewage tank..it was chocolate and children love chocolates " What ever it may be ....but making them work for 6months to 1 years is justified according to your logic?.... “If that’s the case then why do we have a law for child labour..in that case too parents and children are fine but it is punishable under Indian law..”

I definetly feel child would have a problem If he is provided the taste of good education he will never go work…..Then child right commission should act…..Indian child right law is too complicated so I feel it is waste to comment on that…..more number of rules will result more complications…

“It was not a sewage tank..it was chocolate and children love chocolates ”

What ever it may be ….but making them work for 6months to 1 years is justified according to your logic?….

]]> By: Adithya http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-19 Adithya Sun, 22 Mar 2009 18:48:38 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-19 "According to me….If the parents/children have no problem in going for campaign then child right commission should not have any say on the issue"... If that's the case then why do we have a law for child labour..in that case too parents and children are fine but it is punishable under Indian law.. "campaigning under sun is far better than jumping into a sewage tank and run all the place and do such many things…" It was not a sewage tank..it was chocolate and children love chocolates :) “According to me….If the parents/children have no problem in going for campaign then child right commission should not have any say on the issue”…
If that’s the case then why do we have a law for child labour..in that case too parents and children are fine but it is punishable under Indian law..

“campaigning under sun is far better than jumping into a sewage tank and run all the place and do such many things…”

It was not a sewage tank..it was chocolate and children love chocolates :)

]]> By: Abhiram http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-9 Abhiram Sat, 21 Mar 2009 17:11:48 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-9 "<i>Movies and elections are just not comparable.They enjoyed doing the film and when you are getting paid for what u enjoy thats a bonus.</i>" why do u think elections is not fun?.....even these kids are paid more than wat they are paid for slumdog.....then wats wrong? "<i>On the other hand children campaigning under the hot sun just because some party wants to attract voters is not the right way to go.</i>" campaigning under sun is far better than jumping into a sewage tank and run all the place and do such many things.....it is far better...in elections they campaign may be for just 1 or 2 days....but in a movie they work for 6months to 1 year.....so they are loosing out more time on movies rather than election campaign..... According to me....If the parents/children have no problem in going for campaign then child right commission should not have any say on the issue.....it is purely their personal issue.... “Movies and elections are just not comparable.They enjoyed doing the film and when you are getting paid for what u enjoy thats a bonus.”

why do u think elections is not fun?…..even these kids are paid more than wat they are paid for slumdog…..then wats wrong?

“On the other hand children campaigning under the hot sun just because some party wants to attract voters is not the right way to go.”

campaigning under sun is far better than jumping into a sewage tank and run all the place and do such many things…..it is far better…in elections they campaign may be for just 1 or 2 days….but in a movie they work for 6months to 1 year…..so they are loosing out more time on movies rather than election campaign…..

According to me….If the parents/children have no problem in going for campaign then child right commission should not have any say on the issue…..it is purely their personal issue….

]]> By: http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-7 Sat, 21 Mar 2009 07:18:12 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-7 Movies and elections are just not comparable.They enjoyed doing the film and when you are getting paid for what u enjoy thats a bonus.On the other hand children campaigning under the hot sun just because some party wants to attract voters is not the right way to go. Movies and elections are just not comparable.They enjoyed doing the film and when you are getting paid for what u enjoy thats a bonus.On the other hand children campaigning under the hot sun just because some party wants to attract voters is not the right way to go.

]]> By: Abhiram http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-6 Abhiram Sat, 21 Mar 2009 06:37:38 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-6 "<i>The Child Rights Commission may have something to say about all this.At a time when they should be going to school its shameful that congress will be using them for their selfish motives.</i>" If taking children for political campaigning is wrong then even making them act in movies is also wrong....so slumdog itself is wrong.... “The Child Rights Commission may have something to say about all this.At a time when they should be going to school its shameful that congress will be using them for their selfish motives.”

If taking children for political campaigning is wrong then even making them act in movies is also wrong….so slumdog itself is wrong….

]]> By: http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-5 Fri, 20 Mar 2009 21:07:47 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-5 There have been many films that have been made on slums before Slumdog and much better ones too.Not taking any credit away from the film unit.I personally liked the movie The movie might have won many oscars but congress taking credit for it so absurd..Slums have existed in India for a long time and there have been many governments that have come and gone so congress making such silly remarks is a big mistake on their part.Hope some sense prevails and they concentrate on their manifesto and not on how to rope in celebrities(The kids attended the Oscar ceremony) for their campaigning There have been many films that have been made on slums before Slumdog and much better ones too.Not taking any credit away from the film unit.I personally liked the movie The movie might have won many oscars but congress taking credit for it so absurd..Slums have existed in India for a long time and there have been many governments that have come and gone so congress making such silly remarks is a big mistake on their part.Hope some sense prevails and they concentrate on their manifesto and not on how to rope in celebrities(The kids attended the Oscar ceremony) for their campaigning

]]> By: Satish Gandham http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-3 Satish Gandham Fri, 20 Mar 2009 20:02:45 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-3 "I can’t stop laughing when Congress says that it is because of their good governance that films such as slumdog have been made." If there are no slums in India, there is no slumdog. So credit should definitely be given to Congress for slumdog. “I can’t stop laughing when Congress says that it is because of their good governance that films such as slumdog have been made.”

If there are no slums in India, there is no slumdog. So credit should definitely be given to Congress for slumdog.

]]> By: Satish Gandham http://aditalks.com/2009/03/politics/slumdog-politics/comment-page-1/#comment-2 Satish Gandham Fri, 20 Mar 2009 20:02:04 +0000 http://aditalks.com/blog/?p=5#comment-2 Good Luck with your blog dude Good Luck with your blog dude

]]>